The idea that the British monarchy is a symbol of duty or sacrifice is “a lie”, Labour MP Clive Lewis has said.
The former shadow cabinet minister said the royal family in fact risked nothing for its privileged position and served as a distraction from the UK’s social ills.
His comments are likely to enrage Labour leader Keir Starmer, who last week issued orders for MPs to keep quiet in the wake of Queen Elizabeth’s death.
In an article for The Guardian newspaper, published on Saturday, Mr Lewis, a former shadow defence secretary and a veteran of the Afghanistan War, said the institution of the royal family provided cover for politicians.
“It is a spectacle exalted for exemplifying virtues that should be typical in public life and public behaviour,” he wrote.
“Casting such behaviour as exceptional allows the likes of Boris Johnson, Liz Truss and the economic elites they represent to break and exploit the rules for their own benefit and that of their very narrow class interest – of which the monarchy is an integral part.”
Guidance issued to Labour MPs by the leader’s office this week said they should make no comment to the media beyond giving tribute to the Queen and “suspend all campaigning and party activity”.
Criticising the narrative around the monarch’s death, Mr Lewis added: “While republicans should respect the language of ‘duty’ and ‘sacrifice’ monarchists have so forcefully claimed that the royal family makes on our behalf, we should not pretend that the reality is anything other than a lie.
“That is not what monarchy is. It may provide a symbolic way for us to recognise other people’s sacrifice and commitment to society – but the monarchy itself risks nothing and does not suffer, save for having the lives of the royal family become the stuff of celebrity gossip.
Members of the public stand in the queue near Tower Bridge, and opposite the Tower of London, as they wait in line to pay their respects to the late Queen Elizabeth II, in London
AFP via Getty Images
Members of the public in the queue on in Potters Fields Park, central London, as they wait to view Queen Elizabeth II lying in state ahead of her funeral on Monday
PA
The first members of the public pay their respects as the vigil begins around the coffin of Queen Elizabeth II in Westminster Hall, London, where it will lie in state ahead of her funeral on Monday
PA
Crowds cheer as King Charles III and Camilla, Queen Consort arrive for a visit to Hillsborough Castle
Getty
Crowds line the Royal Mile, Edinburgh, as King Charles III joins a procession from the Palace of Holyroodhouse to St Giles’ Cathedral following the coffin of Queen Elizabeth II
Katielee Arrowsmith/SWNS
Members of the Public pay their respects as the hearse carrying the coffin of Queen Elizabeth II, draped in the Royal Standard of Scotland, is driven through Ballater
AFP/Getty
Britain’s Prince William, Prince of Wales, Britain’s Catherine, Princess of Wales, Britain’s Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex, Britain’s Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, wave at well-wishers on the Long walk at Windsor Castle
AFP/Getty
King Charles III and Camilla, Queen Consort wave after viewing floral tributes to the late Queen Elizabeth II outside Buckingham Palace
Getty
A screen commemorating Britain’s Queen Elizabeth II in Piccadilly Circus, London Britain
EPA
Police officers stand guard after Animal Rebellion activists threw paint on the walls and road outside the Houses of Parliament in protest, in London, Britain
Reuters
Queen Elizabeth II welcomes Liz Truss during an audience at Balmoral, Scotland, where she invited the newly elected leader of the Conservative party to become Prime Minister and form a new government
PA
Visitors at the PoliNations garden in Victoria Square, Birmingham, which is made up of five 40ft high tree installations and over 6,000 plants. The PoliNations programme aims to explore how migration and cross-pollination have shaped the UK’s gardens and culture
PA
Undergraduates at the University of St Andrews take part in the traditional Pier Walk along the harbour walls of St Andrews before the start of the new academic year
PA
The Massed Pipes and Drums parade during the Braemar Highland Gathering at the Princess Royal and Duke of Fife Memorial Park
PA
Number 12 Company Irish Guards at Wellington Barracks, central London, before commencing their first Guard Mount at Buckingham Palace
PA
A salmon leaps up the weir at Hexham in Northumberland, despite the drought warnings and low water levels, the River Tyne is still flowing well allowing the salmon and sea trout to head up river to spawn. Every year tens of thousands of salmon make the once-in-a-lifetime journey along the Tyne to spawn, having been out a sea
PA
Flowers are placed at the gates outside Kensington Palace, London, the former home of Diana, Princess of Wales, on the 25th anniversary of her death
PA
Edinburgh’s waste workers clearing mountains of rubbish at Forrest Road as they return to work following their 11 days of industrial action
PA
Competitors take part in the World Gravy Wrestling Championships at the Rose ‘N’ Bowl, in Rossendale, Lancashire
PA
People from the Emancipated Run Crew who are running the carnival parade all in green to remember the 72 people that died in the Grenfell fire during the Family Day at the Notting Hill Carnival in London, which returned to the streets for the first time on two years, after it was thwarted by the pandemic
PA
Competitors in the bog section during Rude Health Bog Triathlon at Llanwrtyd Wells, in Wales
PA
Britain’s Prime Minister Boris Johnson meets patient Rita Thomson after she had a complete hip replacement during a visit to South West London Orthopaedic Centre
Getty
Finney Harrod receiving his GCSE results at Norwich School, in Norwich, Norfolk
PA
A young girl lays a tribute in Kingsheath Avenue, Knotty Ash, Liverpool, where nine-year-old Olivia Pratt-Korbel was fatally shot on Monday night
PA
Florists prepare the entrance to 10 Downing Street with flowers in the Ukraine national colors in London
AP
17-year-old pilot Mack Rutherford lands at Biggin Hill Airport, Westerham, Kent, as he continues in his bid to beat the Guinness World Record for the youngest person to fly around the world solo in a small plane
PA
Members of the Unite union man a picket line at one of the entrances to the Port of Felixstowe in Suffolk, Britain’s biggest and busiest container port, after backing industrial action by 9-1 in a dispute over pay
PA
A young girl dances in Belfast City Centre during the first Mela Carnival, in which participants from more than 20 different cultura groups don traditional costumes to celebrate Northern Ireland’s cultural diversity
PA
Commuters queue for buses outside Victoria underground train station which is closed due to strike action
Getty
Pupils celebrate with their A-level results at Norwich School, Norwich
PA
Rishi Sunak looks at a NLAW anti tank launcher, supplied to Ukraine, during a campaign visit to Thales Defence System plant in Belfast, as part of his campaign to be leader of the Conservative Party and the next prime minister
PA
Protesters gather outside Perth Concert Hall in Scotland, where Conservative leadership hopefuls, Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak are due to take part in an hustings event
PA
A van from the company Bishop’s Move, which specialises in removals, storage and shipping, outside Downing Street, London
PA
A part of a £45m furnace straddles the central reservation as it is moved along the M53 which was closed between junction 5 at Hooton and junction 10 for Cheshire Oaks, to accommodate the abnormal load heading to Essar’s Stanlow refinery
PA
Dry grass in Eastville Park, Bristol. The Met Office has issued an amber warning for extreme heat covering four days from Thursday to Sunday for parts of England and Wales
PA
Dust from a quarry behind a balloon flying at the annual Bristol International Balloon Fiesta
Reuters
Aung-Bo, a 21-year-old asian elephant is cooled down by a keeper at Chester Zoo during the heatwave
Getty
A tanker from Thames Water delivers a temporary water supply to the village of Northend in Oxfordshire, where the water company is pumping water into the supply network following a technical issue at Stokenchurch Reservoir
PA
Students (from left) Sophie Thwaites, Aaliyah McLaine, Michael Stewart, Aaron Boyack and Claire McNab at Auchmuty High School in Glenrothes, Fife, check their results as high school pupils across Scotland find out their exam results
PA
James Willstrop and Declan James of Team England compete with Adrian Waller and Daryl Selby of Team England during the squash men’s doubles gold medal match on the last day of the Commonwealth Games
Getty
Ojie Edoburun of England takes the gold medal in the 4×100 Men’s Relay on Day 10 of the Commonwealth Games in Birmingham
EPA
People walk on parched ground in Greenwich Park in London
EPA
England’s Anthony Harding and England’s Jack Laugher competes to win and take the gold medal in the men’s synchronised 3m springboard diving final on day eight of the Commonwealth Games at Sandwell Aquatics Centre in Birmingham, central England
AFP/Getty
The Top Secret Drum Corps from Switzerland during the working rehearsal for this year’s Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo, entitled Voices, at Redford Barracks, Edingburgh
PA
England’s Emily Campbell celebrates after winning gold in the women’s 87+kg weightlifting at the Commonwealth Games
Getty
Circus company Lost in Translation show off some tricks at the top of Calton Hill in Edinburgh
Getty
England’s players celebrate during a victory party in Trafalgar Square in central London
AFP/Getty
England’s striker Chloe Kelly celebrates after scoring her team second goal during the UEFA Women’s Euro 2022 final football match between England and Germany at the Wembley stadium
AFP/Getty
People during Belfast Pride parade which returns to the city for the first time since the pandemic
PA
Maxwell Tall, 2, cries as Mayor of London Sadiq Khan speaks to the media during a visit to Mums for Lungs community group in South Woodford, London, to coincide with the final day of the ULEZ expansion consultation and the publishing of new air quality data
PA
“Through it all, it remains the backbone of a power structure that traces its roots back to feudalism.”
Labour under Sir Keir has held nothing back in its praise for the UK’s hereditary monarchy, with its official Twitter account raising eyebrows on the political left by this week posting a large “God Save the King” graphic.
Sir Keir, himself a member of the monarch’s privy council and a King’s Counsel, has said that the Queen “lived alongside us”.
The party’s conference is set to go ahead as planned in Liverpool next week, however, despite the cancellation of the equivalent Liberal Democrat and TUC gatherings.
